And here we go again.
The new The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, directed by Francis Lawrence, tells the story of one of the most beloved characters in this universe: Haymitch Abernathy, the winner of the 50th Hunger Games, who would later become the mentor of Katniss and Peeta. As a teenager, Haymitch was selected to represent District 12 at the 50th anniversary Hunger Games, and every 25 years, the Games are made particularly special. This time, the number of tributes was doubled. Haymitch, alongside the other tributes from District 12, travels to the Capitol, where he finds unexpected allies and friends who try to help him break the Games and start a revolution. As we all know from the subsequent films, Haymitch ultimately fails, but he does become the winner of the Games and survives, which becomes his personal punishment at the hands of President Snow.
The new installment of The Hunger Games is a massive dystopian epic, with beautiful cinematography, grandiose visuals, and a huge Hollywood cast that, on paper, should satisfy most fans of this film franchise. Beloved characters, a familiar story, some beautiful new details, gorgeous and highly unrealistic yet deliberately superficial-looking locations, and an enormous amount of fan service, with countless references to the previous films. This feels like an event, and it should be. The filmmakers have certainly gone all out to make sure the fans are happy.
However, if you take a step back and look at everything from a broader perspective, Sunrise on the Reaping turns out to be the weakest film in the entire Hunger Games franchise. Because, in reality, the film doesn't have all that much to say. All the ideas, conclusions, and messages it tries to deliver have already been explored in the previous films, and done so much better. We're simply going through a story that follows entirely understandable and predictable tropes, just with characters at different ages. Throughout the film, you're constantly being pushed to feel these epic emotions and understand the grandiosity and scale of what's happening, but it doesn't land because it all seems so forced. The film tries so hard to be a big deal that it doesn't even shy away from throwing in epic slow-motion shots and literal self-repetitions.
The filmmakers seem much more interested in delivering viral moments and giving fans something to scream about when they see familiar characters in the same frame, characters they already know as adults from the original film series, than in actually expanding this world. There's very little effort to show us the Hunger Games, the Capitol, and the districts during a different period between the story of Snow's rise to power and the original Hunger Games quadrilogy.
And it's a shame that fan service has to look like this, sacrificing the quality of the film for a few minutes of emotional reactions on social media.
Haymitch, a poor, uneducated kid from District 12, somehow turns into a philosopher with some bold quotes and a strategist during these Games, all without any real preparation. President Snow, an incredibly intelligent strategist himself, explaining to the protagonist in advance what's waiting for him in the arena. Many scenes that seem important to the characters at that particular moment are simply rushed through on autopilot, because the filmmakers clearly understand that we're already familiar with how everything works. At the same time, they have no problem spending more time on the main character's relationships with little kids from other districts, just to mirror the Katniss and Rue storyline that made such an impression on everyone in the first film. And here, they do it twice.
The Games themselves turn out to be something of a colourful farce. Despite constantly being reminded that this is a bloodbath, that it's brutally violent and absolutely horrifying to watch, the most we get to see in this film is characters being attacked by butterflies and birds. The supposedly brutal deaths, where tributes fight and kill each other, mostly happen somewhere off-screen. All we hear is the sound of a cannon, announcing that yet another person has died.
Considering how developed and rich this universe already is, and the Hunger Games universe is genuinely incredibly well-written, you'd expect at least some new narrative developments or interesting conclusions. But no. Haymitch could have become the Mockingjay, but he didn't. We already knew that. People inside the Capitol had been working for years to destroy it. We already knew that, too. The Games are rigged according to Snow's wishes. We know. We know. We know all of that.
But even with all these familiarities, it's still a good watch. And then we get to the ending of the film.
First, we're given a rather rushed ending that could have been longer and could have told us much more about the characters' motivations and the roles each of them would eventually play in the future of Panem. But no. Instead, we get a quick montage before moving on to something truly awful. The epilogue. Oh God. Please forgive me, all you devoted fans of this saga, but this epilogue is absolutely dreadful. My first thought: it wasn't needed at all. My second thought: it looked terrible. People in the cinema were giggling, and I'm pretty sure that wasn't the reaction the filmmakers were hoping for. The scene simply repeats conclusions that literally everyone would have figured out a long time ago. Yes, it's fan service, but honestly, it was so incredibly out of place. And don't even get me started on those awful wigs and how genuinely comical the whole thing looked.
Despite all of this, the film does have some good moments. And one of the biggest positives is definitely the cast, which genuinely surprised me. Watching the trailers, I was quite worried about how the younger generation would handle their roles, especially alongside such a strong lineup of established adult actors. But Joseph Zada actually does a pretty good job and becomes a genuinely good Haymitch. Mckenna Grace, whom I'm honestly not the biggest fan of as an actress, also looks quite confident on screen.
However, the real stars here are the adults. My MVP is Jesse Plemons as the young Plutarch. Kieran Culkin, Elle Fanning, and Glenn Close are all excellent in their respective roles. I can't say I was particularly impressed by Ralph Fiennes as Coriolanus Snow, though. To me, he somehow felt like an entirely different person compared to the young Coriolanus played by Tom Blyth and Donald Sutherland, who portrayed the character in the original films. But as an ensemble, this cast works really, really well.
Ultimately, The Hunger Games is a franchise people will keep coming back to again and again. But I'm not sure Sunrise on the Reaping will make it into their greatest-hits selection when they revisit this wonderful, fascinating, and multifaceted universe years from now. Because this film feels like the most imperfect instalment in the entire franchise. Its existence might be justified by the desire to return to a beloved universe, but it doesn't really justify itself within the broader context of the story.
And that's unfortunate.
6/10